Fayetteville Has a Wild True Crime History Worthy of All the Podcasts
Fayetteville, North Carolina has been the setting for several notorious crimes that have captured national attention over the years. Heads up that this story will contain information about murder, rape and abuse. This is your trigger warning.
Like most folks I know, I watch whatever true crime documentaries Netflix pops out and wanted to see what kind of true events have happened in my zip code. From brutal family murders to serial killings, these chilling cases reveal the dark underbelly of this southern town.
One of the most infamous crimes is the 1970 murder of the family of Jeffrey MacDonald, an Army doctor and Green Beret stationed at Fort Bragg. MacDonald’s pregnant wife and two young daughters were stabbed and bludgeoned to death in their home on the base. MacDonald himself was found injured and claimed that a group of drug-crazed hippies had broken in and committed the murders. However, investigators began to doubt his story and MacDonald was eventually convicted of the killings in 1979. He is serving three life sentences but continues to maintain his innocence. The case inspired the book and TV miniseries “Fatal Vision“.
In 1985, another shocking family murder rocked Fayetteville. Army Sergeant Timothy Hennis was accused of stabbing to death a mother and two of her young daughters while the father, an Air Force captain, was away. Hennis had adopted a dog from the family days earlier. He was convicted and sentenced to death in a civilian court, but the verdict was overturned. At a retrial in 1989, Hennis was acquitted. However, years later, the Army brought Hennis back into service to court-martial him for the murders using DNA evidence. In 2010, he was again convicted and sentenced to death, marking the first time a person was retried for the same crime by the U.S. military after being acquitted in a state court.
The brutal 2009 kidnapping, rape and murder of 5-year-old Shaniya Davis also drew worldwide attention to Fayetteville. Shaniya’s mother Antoinette Davis reported her missing from their mobile home. Surveillance video later emerged showing Mario McNeill carrying Shaniya at a hotel in Sanford. The girl’s body was found six days later in a ditch in Lee County. Prosecutors said Antoinette Davis had given her daughter to McNeill to settle a drug debt. McNeill was convicted and sentenced to death. Antoinette Davis pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and is serving at least 17 years in prison.
In 1995, Fayetteville was the site of a racially motivated double murder by neo-Nazi soldiers. Jackie Burden and Michael James, a Black couple, were gunned down on the street by two white Army paratroopers, James Burmeister and Malcolm Wright. Prosecutors said Burmeister was trying to earn a racist spider web tattoo by killing a Black person. Both men were convicted.
Other notorious Fayetteville crimes include:
– The 1993 mass shooting at Luigi’s Italian restaurant on McPherson Church Road left four dead and at least seven wounded. Army sergeant Kenneth French opened fire in the restaurant with a shotgun and rifle before being shot by an off-duty police officer working security nearby.
– The 1985 “Bitter Blood” killing spree by Susie Lynch and Fritz Klenner that claimed nine lives, including Lynch’s parents and grandmother.
– The still-unsolved 2012 beating death of UNC student Faith Hedgepeth in her off-campus apartment.
– In the late 1980s, Fayetteville was terrorized by the “Gas Mask Rapist”. One Reddit user shared that the rapist tried to break into their rented trailer while helicopters searched overhead, before eventually being caught. Not much is known about the total number of his victims or his identity.
Like most cities, Fayetteville has no shortage of tragic and disturbing true crime tales. With its large military presence and transient population, the city has been the backdrop for sensational murders that have gripped the nation. While justice has been served in many cases, the pain inflicted on victims, families and the community as a whole lingers on. These dark chapters serve as a sobering reminder of the evil and violence that can lurk beneath the surface of any town.
.